Artisan Pizza Crafted With Old World Tradition

Pizza, Pasta & Everything In Between

Order Now
Penne Vodka

Penne Vodka

Fresh mozzarella, rich vodka sauce, hot honey, and handcrafted dough come together beautifully.

Add Item
Cannolis

Cannolis

Fresh tomatoes, rich cheeses, savory meats, and handcrafted dough define every bite.

Add Item
Penne Vodka

Penne Vodka

Fresh Italian flavors featuring handcrafted pizza, rich pasta, and classic cannolis.

Add Item
Penne Vodka

Penne Vodka

Fresh tomatoes, rich cheeses, herbs, and bold Italian flavors define every dish.

Add Item

Welcome to Olivia's

Welcome to Olivia's

Savor the true taste of New York-style pizza alongside traditional Italian favorites, all crafted with premium, fresh ingredients. Our mission is bringing Little Silver exceptional cuisine that delights every palate while keeping family dining affordable and enjoyable.

Order Now

Pickup, Delivery or Dine In

Pickup, Delivery or Dine In

Order online for pickup or delivery, take a table in the dining room, or eat outside on the patio. The kitchen is open seven days a week.

Order Now
Square pizza cut into slices and topped with cupped pepperoni

Catering

Feeding a Crowd

Catering is on the menu, with half trays of pasta, chicken and salads. Call the restaurant and we will put the order together with you.

Call (732) 219-7766

What Our Neighbors Say

Recent reviews from our guests.

TechN0va

TechN0va

This place is awesome you'd never know it's there but the pizza is awesome! Definitely Worth a stop.

Daniel

Daniel

In town on vacation from Pennsylvania I was missing Italian food, we found Olivia’s on our ride back from red bank. So happy we did. Some of the best pasta I’ve had. As well as the garlic knots. Big chunks of garlic. Absolutely awesome and delicious. Highly recommend and it’s now going to be on our spots to stop when ... we’re in town. Thanks again guys!

John Cardinale

John Cardinale

Amazing pizza some of the best gluten free pizza

ottaviano lobuglio

ottaviano lobuglio

Best pizza in town

Evan Berk

Evan Berk

10 of us, including 5 under the age of 12, stopped here on the way home from a shore weekend. Food was terrific, as was the service. Portions were large, and the staff couldn’t have been more accommodating. Highly recommend!

Daniel Irvine

Daniel Irvine

If you haven’t been to Olivia‘s in Little Silver, you’re simply not living! I was there the other day with my girlfriend speaking to the owner, Johnny. What a nice guy and he is extremely passionate about his food. We had the traditional pizza with semolina crust, which was amazing. We also had the Josh salad.. You ... can tell he uses the freshest and finest ingredients around. At the end of the meal, he gave us some incredible homemade cannolis on the house. I will make sure to be back soon!

Ottaviano Lobuglio

Ottaviano Lobuglio

At Olivia trattoria artisan pizza it's the Best pizza subs and dinners money can buy .most important friendly crew John the owner with workers that make you feel at home and very clean.give you 5 stars because you deserve them

Sean Kelly

Sean Kelly

Great pizza!! You can tell they use only top quality ingredients. The place is awesome!! If you haven't been u gotta go!!

Miriam Carson

Miriam Carson

I ordered delivery so couldn’t comment on atmosphere. We love the food and so many choices!! Will keep ordering from Olivia’s!

Angi DeSpee

Angi DeSpee

What a great spot. Traveling from MN and really wanted some great Italian, and we definitely found it. The stuffed shells were 10/10 and my husband raved about his penne vodka. The staff was so welcoming and friendly, even gave us some cannolis on the house for dessert. We'd come back here for sure!

Tree P

Tree P

Food is amazing! Mussels appetizers have so much flavor! Can’t wait to order again.

brian

brian

We catered Olivia’s for an event, and all the food was amazing! Our guests especially loved the penne vodka and chicken parm - I would definitely recommend those! Not to mention, their service was also great. Great management and staff!

Natasha Alvarado

Natasha Alvarado

Love this place! Friendly good energy vibe with the staff! Food is amazing try everything 🩷 you can’t beat the prices here!

Christine McKeon

Christine McKeon

Delicious food and exceptional service every time! The pasta dishes are always fresh and delicious, the pizza is perfectly cooked with a great crust, and the antipasto is a standout with the best balsamic dressing. Our go to spot we keep coming back to!

Frequently Asked Questions

What type of cuisine do you serve?

What services do you offer?

What areas do you serve?

Find Us on Prospect Avenue

Open seven days a week for lunch and dinner.

Map of Olivia's Trattoria & Artisan Pizza - 507 Prospect Ave, Little Silver, NJ, 07739, US